Implementing additional fees for plastic bags

By admin, in Observations on .

As Jakarta and Indonesia in general are starting to embrace a “greener” philosophy, numerous efforts have been taken by both the government and private sectors to combat the ever-deteriorating waste situation. A few years back, the city of Bandung was faced with the grim situation of having waste overflowing from its garbage compounds due to the lack of space for the proper disposal of trash. Jakarta itself has experienced something similar. Jakarta’s main landfill of Bantar Gebang in Bekasi has been wrought with numerous problems throughout the year mainly because waste processing in the city can’t keep up with the influx of garbage from citizens.

In an effort to curb waste production, the government of Indonesia in collaboration with the Association of Retail Businesses of Indonesia (Aprindo) introduced a legislation back in February 2016 to apply a small fee for consumers who wish to use plastic bags whenever they buy groceries. This initiative mirrors several regulations that have been in effect throughout countries around the world such as the United Kingdom, Denmark, and France.

It goes without saying, the country’s plan to charge for plastic bags across 22 cities in the archipelago has been met with vigour discourse among citizens. The Environmental and Forestry Ministry’s head of public relations, Novrizal Tahar explained that the new legislation was meant to lighten the burden of waste matters in Indonesia, which has become “serious” in his own words. “In the beginning, this was about reducing garbage, in which plastic bags are considered one of them. In reality, this program is also about shaping the people’s understanding and mind-set towards trash, specifically those that are plastic,” Novrizal said to VIVA in February 2016.

Based on data from the Environmental and Forestry Ministry, Indonesia is the world’s second biggest consumers of plastic bags after China, at 9.8 billion bags per year. This in turn has made Indonesia as also the world’s second biggest producer of plastic waste at 5.4 million tons per year. “Based on these statistics, Indonesia’s domestic plastic waste production accounts for fourteen-percent of all waste that’s produced in the country,” said the head of Indonesia Solid Waste Association (InSWA) Sri Bebassari. Therefore it’s evident that the reduction of plastic waste may lead to significant ramifications in the future.

Behind all the data and statistics, real-world applications and effects are all that matters. Even though it’s still too early to tell whether the charges will actually influence waste production, the fees for plastic bags has certainly divided the public’s opinion with numerous people taking opposing stances on this matter. Some claim that it’s irresponsible of the government to burden the consumers when it comes to environmental programs. While others came out and said that a minimum fee of Rp.200 and at most Rp.5,000 is insignificant and therefore will not have as big of an effect on what the government hopes to accomplish.

Compared to other countries who have already applied a ban or additional taxes on plastic bags, the fee in Indonesia is still relatively cheap. First levied in 2002, Ireland applied a €0.22 tax for plastic bags or around Rp.3,300. France has imposed a fee of €0.54 or around Rp.8,000 for each reusable plastic bag ever since 2007. England has applied a charge of five pence since October 2015, which translates to around Rp.1,000 per plastic bag. In lieu of the charges, the government of the United Kingdom is expected to save up to £60 million in litter clean-up costs. Since its conception in Denmark, it is thought that the extra fees have saved about 66% of plastic and paper bags.

Based on the examples from these countries, it remains to be seen if Indonesia will follow a similar path of success. Even though the intention is well-intended, the regulations still raises a lot of question marks, namely where and what the funds collected will be utilised for. The head of the Consumer’s Foundation of Indonesia (YLKI), Tulus Abadi, has suggested that funds from the plastic bag fees should be managed by an independent body or a special branch of the government. “This special organisation can be composed of government officials and private citizens. It has to be audited each year and the funds can’t be touched by retail companies, nor should they have any business managing the funds,” Tulus said to Tempo.

The efforts to reduce plastic waste will hopefully culminate into the Gerakan Indonesia Bebas Sampah or the Indonesia Free of Waste Movement –a campaign to create a garbage-free Indonesia by the year 2020. Based on the additional fees of plastic bags, both the direction and intent is clear. However as stated above, there still needs to be a clearer regulation that oversees the management of funds and its appropriation. Ultimately, it’s a step in the right direction to solve the increasing dangers of uncontrolled waste production.






Rina Alfrina – Media Planner


What’s your opinion on the paid plastic bags policy in supermarkets?

I honestly think it’s a good idea. It could be a start to reduce the plastic wastes. Other countries have already done it before us, so it’s a good start for Indonesia to be more responsible in keeping our Earth clean.

How often do you use a plastic bag?

Only if I have lots of groceries. If I only buy one or two things, I’d rather just put it on my personal bag, even before this policy was created.

Do you think the fee for the plastic bag is suitable?

Well I think it could be a little higher. For Rp.200, many would see that it’s not a big deal and keep using plastic bags anyway. Maybe Rp.1,000 would be good for one plastic bag, and the government could use the money to do something else to save the environment.

What else do you think the government should do to manage our plastic waste?

I think the government should educate the people more about dangers of plastic use and how it’s not easily degraded.

Do you think most Indonesians overuse plastic bags?

Indeed! We use plastics in almost every part of our daily life, especially foods. No wonder trash is piling up in our rivers and cause floods.



Irum Rahmi – Housewife

What’s your opinion on the paid plastic bags policy in supermarkets?

I’m quite surprised. I never realised plastic bags can be a huge problem. We usually don’t just throw it away, we use plastic bags to keep and store all sorts of things.

How often do you use a plastic bag?

Very often. Either from the supermarket, minimarket, or traditional market, I always use plastic bags to carry groceries.

Do you think the fee for the plastic bag is suitable?

It’s just Rp.200, so I don’t think that would make me want to stop using plastic bags right away. It’s not expensive and therefore it doesn’t feel like a financial burden.

What else do you think the government should do to manage our plastic waste?

The government need to manage better where the trash and waste go so it doesn’t pile up. That’s what I think causes so much plastic waste.



Yadi – Store clerk

What’s your opinion on the paid plastic bags policy in supermarkets?

It’s something new that we should learn. Not many of our customers know about this new policy, so we need to remind them that plastic bags aren’t free now.

Do they complain about it?

Yes, usually it’s the housewives who complain about that. We keep explaining that it’s not the store policy, rather it came from the government.

Since the new policy has been enforced, has there been any cutback of people using plastic bags?

Not really. People think it’s still quite cheap so they don’t mind paying for it. But I also see an increase in people bringing their own non-plastic shopping bags now.

Do you think this policy will succeed in reducing the amount of plastic waste?

I can’t say nor would I know about it at this point, because it’s just the start. Maybe in the future people will come to terms with the problems plastic waste brings and not overuse it anymore.


generic cialis at walmart finasteride 5mg side effects mayo clinic cialis patent expiration date extended cialis effects liquid cialis cialis 10 mg post finasteride syndrome what does ciprofloxacin 500mg treat cialis coupons 2017 azithromycin 250mg tablets 6 pack vardenafil 20mg cialis samples overnight cialis from canada acyclovir dosage what is cipro used for azithromycin without a doctor’s prescription side effects of azithromycin 250 mg cialis 20mg finasteride effets secondaires viamedic cialis cilias zovirax cream revatio vs viagra viagra tablets escitalopram oxalate erectile dysfunction cialis side effects of cialis zithromax cialis alternative lexapro para que sirve cialis coupon 20 mg cialis canada what is tamoxifen used for acyclovir ointment viagra receptfritt cialis professional price cialis tamoxifen side effects in women cialis vs viagra cialis 5mg cialas cialis vs viagra viagra pill cialis on line azithromycin drug class finasteride 5mg tab azithromycin tablet what works better than viagra ciprofloxacin hydrochloride ophthalmic finasteride 1mg viagra bestellen acyclovir 400 mg cialis pills pfizer viagra coupons from pfizer tamoxifen side effects lexapro and weight gain zovirax dosage effects of stopping finasteride viagra alternatives 9 levitra at walmart cialis free trial cialis generic levitra dosage viagra pillen kruidvat viagra 100 viagra without a doctor prescription ciprofloxacin spc ciprofloxacin when will cialis go generic what is cialis viagra ohne rezept auf rechnung acyclovir dose cialis canadian pharmacy lexapro generic name azithromycine levitra 20 mg von bayer viagra side effects azithromycin and alcohol viagra prices ciprofloxacin drops acyclovir for cold sores viagra single packs buying viagra what is cipro usually prescribed for discount cialis side effects of viagra stopping lexapro lexapro dosing cialis coupons from manufacturer how much does cialis cost finasteride reviews ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics side effects ciprofloxacin dosage cialis pricing viagra without a doctor prescription usa lexapro 10mg ciprofloxacin for dogs cialis 20 mg zovirax ointment levitra bayer 20mg meilleur prix generic viagra finasteride permanent side effects azithromycin pregnancy category finasteride medication levitra 20 mg is tamoxifen chemotherapy is azithromycin penicillin buy cialis cipro drug class cialis coupon lexapro side effects men azithromycin vs erythromycin tamoxifen therapy viagra natural generic cialis azithromycin cialis for women zovirax canadian cialis ciprofloxacin 250 mg viagra 100mg what does azithromycin treat does lexapro cause weight gain side effects of acyclovir levitra prices cipro 500 viagra vs cialis lexapro withdrawal symptoms viagra alternative lexapro vs wellbutrin lexapro vs zoloft escitalopram 10 mg para que sirve what is lexapro used for cialis patent expiration cialis without a doctor’s prescription ciprofloxacin side effects ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg side effects cyalis what bacteria does ciprofloxacin kill azithromycin class azithromycin z pak zithromax dosage cialis dosage strengths ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics propecia cialis savings card viagra soft cialis coupon print azithromycin medscape what does ciprofloxacin treat thuoc azithromycin cialis online ciprofloxacin drug class ciprofloxacin dose viagra price azithromycin coverage azithromycin tablets cialis 5 mg viagra coupons daily cialis how does lexapro work acyclovir 800 mg 5 times a day levitra rezeptfrei deutschland what is ciprofloxacin prescribed for cipro side effects how to get off lexapro tamoxifen and foods to avoid viagra for men acyclovir dosing finasteride side effects viagra en ligne livraison 24h sex viagra for women cost of viagra ciprofloxacin 500 mg women viagra ciprofloxacin side effects after age 60 viagra costs cialis for daily use natural viagra buy cialis online side effects of lexapro in women tamoxifen nebenwirkungen viagra uk acyclovir 400mg cialis 30 day trial coupon levitra prezzo in farmacia lexapro and weight gain in women escitalopram side effects wellbutrin and lexapro cialis cost acyclovir medication viagra 100 mg viagra pills what infections does ciprofloxacin treat lexapro side effects in women cialis testimonials side effects of azithromycin tamoxifen and weight gain how to use viagra lexapro overdose cialis prices how to wean off lexapro without withdrawals ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab buy viagra cialis discount levitra side effects of lexapro 10 mg viagra from canada generic for cialis azithromycin cost levitra 20 mg cost walmart finasteride and enlarged prostate cialis dosage best price viagra what is ciprofloxacin used for cialis voucher azithromycin for strep throat how does acyclovir work ciprofloxacin used for viagra for sale uk buy generic levitra levitra 20mg cost per pill tamoxifen langzeitfolgen viagra for women cialis for men finasteride dosage cialis generic availability lexapro dosage cialis dosage recommendations viagra tesco levitra vs viagra for hardness acyclovir cream what does viagra do what is ciprofloxacin how long does viagra last viagra vs cialis vs levitra cialis samples viagra sex azithromycin pregnancy tamoxifen cost generic cialis tadalafil free cialis escitalopram effets secondaires what is cipro levitra vs viagra tamoxifen interaction viagra cialis cialis coupons printable cipro side effects in elderly sophia viagra tamoxifen citrate propecia side effects lexapro bula what is escitalopram viagra on line what is lexapro cialis website acyclovir ointment 5 azithromycin uses how to take cialis celexa vs lexapro escitalopram 10 mg how long for azithromycin to take effect online cialis viagra 100mg tablets retail price finasteride 5mg side effects tamoxifen lawsuits 200 cialis coupon acyclovir 200mg cialis trial azithromycin 250 mg treatment viagra cost lexapro medication cialis pills for sale what is acyclovir for how long for lexapro to work finasteride 5 mg canada viagra lexapro 20mg lexapro 5mg finasteride hair loss ciprofloxacin 500 mg for urinary tract infection viagra kaufen acyclovir 800 mg finasteride viagra wiki viagra substitute ciprofloxacin side effects in women viagra vs cialis generic viagra 100mg cialis or viagra cialis cheap cialis otc how does cialis work viagra samples cipro for uti cialis generic tadalafil cialis price cialis pharmacy prices acyclovir side effects order viagra cipro dosage lexapro manufacturer website where to buy viagra azithromycin liquid pfizer viagra how does viagra work cost of cialis zovirax pills cipro dangers what is finasteride used for azithromycin pediatric dosing cialis reviews cheap viagra antibiotic ciprofloxacin lexapro generic tamoxifen side effects in women over 55 finasteride efectos secundarios azithromycin 500 erfahrungen cipro cialis 5mg daily discount viagra finasteride for women ciprofloxacin hcl nolvadex weaning off lexapro canada cialis side effects of ciprofloxacin azithromycin 500 cialis 20mg directions acyclovir vs valacyclovir cialis coupons what is acyclovir used for lexapro for anxiety ciprofloxacin 500 zithromax 500 mg lexapro vs celexa zovirax for cold sores side effects of tamoxifen finasteride vs dutasteride tamoxifen effects of stopping lexapro suddenly ciprofloxacin ophthalmic solution side effects of finasteride lexapro side effects finasteride 5 mg tab ciprofloxacin 500mg is ciprofloxacin a penicillin wholesale cialis what is azithromycin for what is viagra finasteride tablets viagra wikipedia how to wean off lexapro ciprofloxacin class finasteride long term effects azithromycin 5 day dose pack ciprofloxacin hydrochloride azithromycine 250 mg ciprofloxacin 250mg ciprofloxacin uses vardenafil vs viagra levitra 10 mg prezzo acyclovir azithromycin for pneumonia lexapro levitra 20 mg precio farmacia finasteride side effects in men finasteride results viagra cealis cipro antibiotics cipro and tendonitis buy levitra online viagra generic azithromycin three times a week cialis 30 day sample tamoxifen bijwerkingen cialis tadalafil viagra vs cialis vs levitra viagra medicine first few days on lexapro lexapro and wellbutrin combination therapy viagra tablet ciprofloxacin 500mg tablets cipro uses equipe argentine viagra azithromycin 500 mg acyclovir 800mg escitalopram 20 mg cipro antibiotic what is finasteride azithromycine eg 500 mg bijsluiter viagra sans ordonnance cheap cialis levitra generic cialis medication zoloft vs lexapro viagra canada female viagra generic levitra vardenafil 20mg over the counter viagra buy generic viagra ciprofloxacin bnf levitra erfahrungen azithromycin dosage lexapro weight gain cialis daily azithromycin 250 mg common side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg lexapro reviews generic for lexapro ciprofloxacin coverage ciprofloxacin eye drops levitra coupon azithromycin 250mg lexapro 10 mg side effects of lexapro levitra online escitalopram 10mg lexapro withdrawal side effects of finasteride 5mg withdrawal from lexapro canadian viagra levitra vs viagra is azithromycin viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland what is lexapro for lexapro benefits for women what is azithromycin levitra coupons azithromycin eye drops escitalopram side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 mg escitalopram nebenwirkungen side effects lexapro what is tamoxifen cialis for sale tamoxifen and bone pain what is azithromycin used for cialis patent expiration 2017 viagra effects acyclovir 800 mg for shingles free viagra cialis copay card viagra nebenwirkungen viagra 50mg lexapro side effects in men viagra on line no prec viagra coupon lexapro and weight loss herbal viagra viagra dosage is lexapro a controlled substance viagra generico viagra online zithromax antibiotic what is acyclovir utilisation viagra cialis generic lexapro buy viagra online lexapro dosages acyclovir for shingles what does finasteride do levitra without a doctor prescription viagra activate cialis for bph viagra for sale generic levitra levitra 20mg finasteride for hair loss finasteride 5mg azithromycin 500mg zithromax z-pak azithromycin side effects lowest cialis prices cheap levitra ciprofloxacin 500 mg tabletten azithromycin 250 ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg acyclovir dosage for cold sores buy levitra ciprofloxacin dosierung online viagra lexapro coupons azithromycin for uti cialis side effects ciprofloxacin nebenwirkungen cialis sample

Recommended articles